Churches not Prisons

Building the temple

11 Now the word of the Lord came to Solomon, 12 ‘Concerning this house that you are building, if you will walk in my statutes, obey my ordinances, and keep all my commandments by walking in them, then I will establish my promise with you, which I made to your father David. 13 I will dwell among the children of Israel, and will not forsake my people Israel.’
1 Kings 6
In the readings set for tonight’s Evensong we have a story of a temple and a story of a prison. The building of a fine temple and the escape from a prison, a dark and unpleasant place. We have two places as far apart as you could imagine. Each man made, each at opposite ends of the scale of desirability. We would like to visit a temple, we do not want to be in a prison.

Buildings have been very much part of my ministry here. They continue to be a big matter, perhaps the biggest concern for the PCC. Just a couple of weeks ago lead was stolen off the roof and so much work has gone into emergency repair, insurance claim, CCTV, Police and the like. Buildings take time and money. It must be nigh on two hundred thousand that has been spent on repairs to walls, the roof, heating, organs over the last 7 years. And then there are the routine running costs of maintenance - heating, insuring, etc.

Many would say it’s worth it. The young couple who come to St Mary’s holding hands and gaze in wonder up to the rafters. The many who want their family funerals to be here, because they say it looks like “a proper church”. A Diocesan group has looked at churches in the dioceses and considered what might be the criteria to be used by PCCs and others as to whether that Church should be closed. Up the top of the list is keeping what they call “Iconic Buildings”. St Mary’s is surely an iconic building.
 
But what does the building mean? What does it signify or represent? Buildings always say something. We can think what they mean to us - we should also consider what they mean to others.  For many of us this building we are in tonight says come and wonder before God, and share in the meal that our Lord Jesus gave us, come to the table. You are welcome.

But I remember seeing a play at The Everyman Theatre a few years ago when someone referred to our Anglican Cathedral as “A big F*** Off Cathedral”. I don’t like to think about it but it is surely true – at times in the past and perhaps even in the present Church people and Church buildings have said to the outsiders you are not good enough and have said to the insiders – we are the elect, the chosen.

St Mary’s is a fine building - not quite as fine though as Solomon’s temple. What a fine temple it was. There was a lot of gold!

21 Solomon overlaid the inside of the house with pure gold, then he drew chains of gold across, in front of the inner sanctuary, and overlaid it with gold. 22 Next he overlaid the whole house with gold, in order that the whole house might be perfect; even the whole altar that belonged to the inner sanctuary he overlaid with gold.

The Old Testament scholar Ceresko[1] tells how with the death of David, Solomon moved ruthlessly to consolidate his power and establish a firm grip on the apparatus of government. He introduced new taxes and conscripted workmen from all over Israel. He consolidated his power. The temple and his palace were extremely luxurious. Ceresko says this was consolidate Solomon’s monarchic power and it represented a concrete visual statement of the shape and strength of the new socio-economic, religious and political order which Solomon had established.

If we agree with that then Solomon’s temple is like the Shard or Canary Wharf. It says that someone is very rich and wants to make a statement. If you are a feminist or a Freudian you may have something else to add about who has built it and why….!

Yes, I think we must be suspicious of the way human power and earthly empires become gods in their own right. We have seen with horror the human propensity to stake out our territory and to deny others entry. It happens in Israel/Palestine/Gaza. It happens in local communities. But this is I fear too cynical.

The giants have been in Liverpool and Grandma has been sleeping in St George’s Hall. Buildings, perhaps funded by the fruits of slavery are redeemed by the public uses they are put to.

When the people fill the building, and the people’s praises lift the roof, this Church is a temple where the living God is worshipped. The dead are remembered but this is not a mausoleum because the ways of Jesus are talked about and stories and liturgies shape lives in the here and now. Things happen here; people talk, sing, lament, laugh, and cry. People hear the word of God and share the sacrament of Holy Communion. In a place of beauty, God’s beautiful people gather to remember and to commit afresh to do what Mother Teresa called “Something Beautiful for God”.

Another Old Testament scholar Walter Brueggemann has another take on Solomon’s Temple.[2] He says that from Sinai on Israel anticipates a full and rich life with their God, Yahweh. Buildings like Solomon’s temple are a theological statement that Yahweh will be with Israel in all circumstances. There is an accent on the visual – the whole system of tabernacle, priesthood, mercy seat and sacrificial system is both visual and material. You can see it, perhaps smell it. He says that worship that was visual, active dramatic and all-comprehending was a thing of joy for Israel.[3] Yes there may have been a source of power for the Jerusalem political establishment – but that was never the whole story.

Buildings are on my mind as I prepare to go to Rochdale where I shall have two churches in my care – St Chad and St Mary in the Baum. I shall be living adjacent to another, redundant, church, St Edmund’s. There is some fine architecture in all three.

When we worship and sense our freedom to respond to God’s call to us, we cannot but remember those who are in prison. As part of the disproportionately high UK prison population or, in these days, the urban war-zone prison of Gaza. We pray that they may know the beauty of God, somehow.

I hope that our Churches in Rochdale and Liverpool may be places which draw people in to worship that is engaging and transformative. I hope that we facilitate wonder and express welcome. I thank God for all our Architects and musicians which assist people to grow in the love of Jesus and to live lives that are Jesus shaped.








[1] Anthony R. Ceresko, Introduction to the Old Testament: A Liberation Perspective (Maryknoll, N.Y. : London: Orbis Books, 1992).
[2] Walter Brueggemann, Theology of the Old Testament: Testimony, Dispute, Advocacy, Pbk. Ed., with CD-ROM (Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg Fortress, 2005).
[3] Ibid., 669.